Family Genealogy

The Duncan Family

From George Duncan of Scotland to his great-grandson John Duncan Scotland, Ireland, New Hampshire Family of Betsy Duncan Stevens

George Duncan was a native of Scotland and at the time of the great exodus of the Scots of Argyle to Ireland, he left Scotland for Ireland.

That was during the 1690s when tens of thousands of Scots fled a famine in Lowland Scotland and went to Ulster, North Ireland.

From Ireland to New Hampshire, 1729

George's son George was born in the valley of the Bann at Ballymoney in County Antrim in Ulster, North Ireland. He and his family came to America in 1729. Before them the Bell family had come to America - John Bell and his wife Elizabeth Todd. Two of George Duncan's sons married Bell daughters.

John Bell came to America in 1719. He landed at Boston and spent some time in Andover, Mass., before he settled in Londonderry, New Hampshire, in 1720.

George's son William married Naomi Bell. William was born in Ireland about 1713. William lived his life in Londonderry, New Hampshire. He was a deacon of the church and he was also a captain of the militia.

John Duncan of Acworth

William's son John was an early pioneer of Acworth, New Hampshire. John moved to Acworth in 1776. John first married Margaret Dickey. After she died John married Betsy Prouty of Spencer, Massachusetts, on May 15, 1794. They were married by the Rev. Mr. Fisher of the next town, Lempster.

The Acworth town record of the children's births was copied into his pension file in 1848. It lists eight children of John and Margaret and eleven of John and Betsy. Their daughter Betsy, who married Dr. Thomas Stevens, was born April 26, 1813.

Children of John and Margaret Children of John and Betsy
William, Oct 14, 1778
John, March 1, 1780
Adam, Jan 21, 1782
George, Dec 26, 1783
Jane, Oct 17, 1785
Rachel, Nov 23, 1787
Isaac, July 12, 1789
James, July 1, 1791
Daniel, Dec 13, 1794
Hiram, June 30, 1796
Horace, Jan 10, 1799
Fanny, March 4, 1801
Cyrus, May 6, 1803
Harvey, Oct 3, 1805
Milton, April 18, 1808
Solon, Sept 5, 1810
Betsy, April 26, 1813
Theron, Dec 1, 1815
Mary, March 5, 1820

Three of Betsy and John's children died in 1812 during the spotted fever epidemic. Harvey, age 6, Milton, age 4, and Solon, age 1 1/2, all died during the month of March in 1812.

John Duncan was a colonel who served in the Revolution and the War of 1812. He was highly respected in Acworth. Here is a quote from the book History of Acworth:

History of Acworth    1869

We remember Col. John Duncan as one of the early settlers of the town. He was a man of superior ability, possessing an extensive knowledge of men and things, and a great fund of anecdotes. He represented Acworth and Dempster in the convention which met in Exeter, when our State constitution was adopted in 1792.

During the Revolutionary War he served as a Sergeant. Here is another quote from the book History of Acworth:

History of Acworth    1869

John, b. 1752, chopped down the first tree on his farm in Acworth, 1773, but until his marriage in 1778, spent his winters in Londonderry. He responded to his country's call when the news reached Londonderry that the British were marching on Concord, and arrived at Lexington at sunrise the next morning after the first blood had been shed for America's freedom. He also, with several other Acworth men, joined Capt. Bellows' company going through the woods to New York State to assist in intercepting Gen. Burgoyne in his march through New York. In 1780 he was elected with Henry Silsby to attend the convention of the New Hampshire Grants at Charlestown and Cornish, receiving $900 in currency for fourteen days' service, $72 being equal to $1 in silver. From that time for more than fifty years he was prominent in all town business. In matters requiring tact and politic management, he was put forward. He was the most efficient in procuring the settlement of Mr. Cooke at a time when ministerial settlements by the town were becoming unpopular. The characteristic by which he was specially distinguished was shrewdness among neighbors in whom that quality abounded.

The Revolution in his own words

In May 1833, when he was 81, John went before the Probate Court at Charlestown, New Hampshire to apply for a pension. He said he was born in Londonderry on March 29, 1752. Three men who served with him, Deacon Robert McClure, Deacon Lasel Silsby and Jeremiah Willard, swore to his service. You can read every page in the transcript of the pension file, or see the pdf of the pension file.

In his own words    May 13, 1833

That on the nineteenth of April 1775, your declarant then living in Londonderry in New Hampshire, news came that the British had left Boston & were going into the country, & that there was a want of men, your declarant with David McClary, Robert Boyse & David Brewster, immediately shouldered our packs & guns, & started to meet them, we travelled all that night and in the morning of the 20th arrived at Lexington, on the battle ground then stained with the blood of our citizens ...

He told the court about four times he served:

  • April 1775, 22 days. He reached Lexington the morning after the battle and went on to Cambridge, where he and other volunteers guarded the roads from Cambridge, Mystic and Charlestown into Boston. He belonged to no company. A few days after he came home to his father's house in Londonderry, he went to Acworth to live.
  • June 1776, five months. He was a sergeant in Capt. Samuel Wetherbee's company, Col. Wyman's regiment. They marched from Charlestown to Rutland, Vermont, through the woods to Lake Champlain and Ticonderoga, and were stationed at Mount Independence doing military duty and making roads.
  • September 1777, two months. He was a sergeant in Capt. William Carey's company, Col. Bellows' regiment. On a scouting party under Major Whitcomb his party met the regiment at Saratoga, where they "took Burgoyne's boats loaded with provisions, cloathing & munitions of war." They guarded the river crossing at Fort Edward until Burgoyne surrendered, then divided their "plunder or booty from the British" and went home.
  • Fall 1780, nine days. He was a sergeant in Capt. William Keyes' Acworth company when the alarm came that Royalton, Vermont had been burned. They marched toward Newbury but the enemy had gone back to Canada.

The court found that he "was a Revolutionary Soldier, and served as he states." He was given a pension of $31.66 a year starting March 4, 1831.

Sergeant or Colonel?

In the Revolution John was a sergeant. That is the rank in his own declaration, on the company rolls and on his pension. Later he was called Colonel John Duncan. When the government answered a descendant's question in 1934, it said he "was referred to as Colonel John Duncan with no explanation of the rank." The title most likely came from his years in the town's militia after the war. The History of Acworth calls him Capt. Duncan, commander of the military company, in the story below.

The pension file agrees with the History of Acworth that he reached Lexington the morning after the battle. The History says he joined "Capt. Bellows' company" in 1777. His own declaration says it was Capt. William Carey's company in Col. Bellows' regiment.

John Duncan died June 14, 1834 in Acworth, New Hampshire. His neighbor Thomas Dickey was with him when he died. Thomas helped dig his grave and saw him buried on the Sunday after he died. Thomas was also one of the executors of John's will, which was proved in the probate court on June 17, 1834.

His Revolutionary War pension file is number W. 1841. A "W" file is a widow's file, which means his wife Betsy applied for a pension on his service after he died.

Betsy Prouty Duncan in her widowhood

Betsy Prouty lived to be 96 years old. In October 1848, when she was 74, she applied for a widow's pension. She could not write and signed with her mark. She thought John had been paid $72 a year, but the government records show $31.66, and that is what she was given. Her certificate was issued September 29, 1849.

In her old age she lived with her daughter Betsy and her husband Dr. Thomas Stevens in Charlestown, Massachusetts. She is found in their household in the 1850 census. The census taker wrote the head of the household as William Stevens, but this is Thomas Stevens and his family.

On November 1, 1851 she asked to have her pension paid in Massachusetts instead of Concord, New Hampshire, because Concord was "at a great distance." Thomas J. Stevens was her witness. He swore that he was "personally & well acquainted with Betsey Duncan" and that she was who she said she was.

Her daughter Betsy died in 1854. By March 1855 Betsy Prouty was back in Acworth. That month her son Theron was a witness when she applied for bounty land, and she was granted a warrant for 160 acres. In November 1855 she wrote that she lived in Acworth "where my late husband John Duncan resided, with my son where my home and support is." By the 1860 census she is living with her son Theron and his family. Theron was killed in action on May 13, 1864 during the battle of Drewry's Bluff in Virginia. Herbert Bennett, the father of Minerva Bennett who married Betsy's grandson Milan, was hurt in the same battle.

In August 1868, at the age of 93, she applied for a larger pension under a new law for widows who had married before 1800. It was raised to $131.66 a year, back-dated to September 30, 1865. Her lawyer wrote that she was "quite aged and needs the allowance while she lives which may be but a short time." One of her witnesses was B. P. Wood, who had known her for 10 or 30 years.

By 1870 Betsy is living in Acworth with Benjamin P. Wood, his wife and daughter. They do not appear to be related to her. She died in Acworth on January 8, 1871.

"Some I flatter and some I drive"

The people of Acworth delighted in rough practical jokes and boisterous fun. As part of their pioneer life they enjoyed New England rum.

The following incident illustrates their love of practical jokes: While Capt. John Duncan was commander of the military company, some of the younger members headed by Parley Keyes, were guilty of some neglect of duty, and thereby incurred a fine. Keyes had considerable influence in the company, and the Captain foresaw that there might be difficulty in enforcing a collection of the fines. He saw Keyes privately, and unfolded to him a plan whereby he might play a practical joke upon his brother delinquents. At the next training Keyes should step out before the company, acknowledge his fault, pay over the fine, and advise his comrades to do the same. Duncan intimated to him, however, that he would refund to him his own fine. Keyes agreed to play his part of the joke, and the plan worked most admirably, the delinquents following the example of Keyes, walked up and paid their fines. Time passed on, and Keyes not having his money refunded as he expected, complained to the Captain. With a toss of the head, Capt. Duncan replied, "Some I flatter and some I drive."

At a subsequent training, after the above incident had apparently been forgotten, Capt. Duncan, as the custom was, wanting to treat his company, handed some money to Keyes who was a sergeant, and directed him to go to Mr. Henry's store and buy some rum. The liquor came and was used. A few days after Mr. Henry called Capt. Duncan into his store and presented a bill for rum on training day. Capt. Duncan settled the bill, and on meeting Keyes inquired, with much indignation, why he had not paid for the rum. Imitating the captain's manner, he replied, "Some I flatter, and some I drive."

Sources

  1. Lyman Horace Weeks, The Bell Family in America (New York: William M. Clemens, 1913); digital images, Internet Archive (https://archive.org/details/bellfamilyinamer00week).
  2. James Duncan Phillips, "James Duncan of Haverhill, Pack Peddler, Store Keeper, and Merchant," Essex Institute Historical Collections 88 (1952): 1–18; digital text, Internet Archive (https://archive.org/stream/essexinstitutehi88esse/essexinstitutehi88esse_djvu.txt).
  3. Ezra S. Stearns, Genealogical and Family History of the State of New Hampshire, vol. II (Chicago: Lewis Publishing Company, 1908), 607–608; digital images, Google Books (https://books.google.com/books?id=cfoI0UIOCKQC).
  4. Rev. J. L. Merrill, History of Acworth (Acworth, N.H.: The Town, 1869), 126; digital images, Internet Archive (https://archive.org/details/historyofacworth00lcmerr).
  5. Merrill, History of Acworth, 212, John Duncan chopping down the first tree on his farm.
  6. Merrill, History of Acworth, 214, deaths of Harvey, Milton and Solon Duncan, March 1812.
  7. John Duncan (Sgt., N.H.), pension file W. 1841, Betsy Duncan, widow, bounty-land warrant 7206-160-55; "Case Files of Pension and Bounty-Land Warrant Applications Based on Revolutionary War Service, compiled ca. 1800 – ca. 1912, documenting the period ca. 1775 – ca. 1900," National Archives microfilm publication M804, National Archives Catalog ID 300022; Records of the Department of Veterans Affairs, Record Group 15; National Archives, Washington, D.C.; image copy, DuncanJohnRevolutionaryWarPensionFile.pdf; transcript.
  8. Find a Grave, memorial 29980473, Col. John Duncan (https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/29980473).
  9. 1850 U.S. census, Middlesex County, Massachusetts, Charlestown, p. 87B, William [Thomas] Stevens household; National Archives microfilm publication M432, roll 322; database with images, Ancestry, image 130 of 411.
  10. Massachusetts, death record, Betsy Stevens (1854), vol. 85, p. 63, no. 280, Boston; Massachusetts Archives, Boston.
  11. 1860 U.S. census, Sullivan County, New Hampshire, Acworth, p. 976, Theron Duncan household; National Archives microfilm publication M653, roll 681; FHL microfilm 803,681; database with images, Ancestry, image 8 of 30.
  12. "U.S., Civil War 'Widows' Pensions,' 1861–1910," database with images, Fold3, Theron Duncan, widow's certificate WC 32,835.
  13. 1870 U.S. census, Sullivan County, New Hampshire, Acworth, p. 400A, Benjamin P. Wood household; National Archives microfilm publication M593, roll 850; database with images, Ancestry, image 19 of 27.
  14. Find a Grave, memorial 29980472, Betsey Duncan (https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/29980472).